bt - Full Story

May 2010 

Other IBA Media publication EgyptToday

 

  Search  BusinessTodayEgypt

Back Issues  bt Subscribe
 
Current Issue
       Home

      Editor's Note

      The Nation In Brief

      News Focus

      The Good Life

      Features

 
Current Issue
 
 IBA Media
     About bt Egypt
     Advertise with bt
     Contact us
     bt jobs & freelancing

 
 
Home | News Focus  
Printer FriendlyEmail to a friend

By Illustration by Roshdy Saad
News Focus

Burying the Hatchet
The slugfest over Mobinil ends in a draw.

Family Planning
Most family businesses crumble under the forces of change. Yale Professor Kelin Gersick talks about the perils of succession, infighting and what older generations can do to ensure their legacy isn’t squandered.

Who Needs to Advertise?
Some of Egypt’s strongest brands have discovered that you don’t need to spend money on billboards and TV spots to thrive.

Casting Off
Citadel Capital bets big on Nile shipping with plans to pump LE 1 billion into privately-run ports.

A Ring of Truth
The outsourcing industry takes off, but can it reach the government’s lofty targets?

What Do Egyptians Want?
One of the region’s top market researchers, Franck Thureau, talks about the importance of data.

Stuck in the Middle
big for microloans and too small for traditional financing, small businesses struggle to grow.

By Land, By Sea, By Air
Infrastructure projects in the Maghreb are connecting people and markets, ushering in a new era of economic activity in North Africa.

By Jessica Gray

July 2010
Achilles Heel
The crisis in Greece, and the collapse of the euro, could scuttle Egypt’s plans for economic growth.

By Jessica Gray

Europe may have dodged a bullet in May thanks to a nearly $1 trillion (LE 5.6 trillion) bailout for Greece and its debt-laden neighbors, but the long-term future of those countries remains in doubt.

What is clear is that Athens’ near financial meltdown and Europe’s larger sovereign debt crisis could have a major impact on Egypt, say economists.

Severe belt-tightening by the region’s most fragile economies — Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece and Spain — could curtail foreign investment here, limit aid donations and slice into tourist visits. Budget cuts and tax increases, now on the table continent-wide, could also dampen demand for Egyptian exports, about 40% of which are bound for EU-member countries.

The EGX 30 has already felt the pain, plunging 5% on May 9 following global concerns Greece would not make an important 10-year bond repayment later in the month. The drop was the largest single-day dive in two years. (The bourse lost a whopping 360 points to fall to 6756.)

The EU’s financial crisis began to unfold last year after Greece’s new government admitted the previous administration had cooked its books, lying about the country’s staggering debt and public sector obligations.

“I find it hard to believe that European governments didn’t know this. Were they asleep?” says Joseph Trevisani, chief market analyst for FX Solutions, an online foreign exchange brokerage.

Greece’s decline into debt started long before its newly-elected government discovered the shady accounting, and Trevisani says that the country’s problems have not been solved by the bailout.

As the crisis unfolded, other EU-member states were put under the microscope, highlighting Spain, Portugal and Ireland’s own spiraling national debt. Driven by a falling euro, 16 nations teamed up with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to make the $1 trillion (LE 5.6 trillion) available in June.

Though the move boosted numbers on stock exchanges globally, the eurozone is not out of the woods yet, leaving Egypt to suffer economic repercussions of yet another financial meltdown.

In May, Economic Development Minister Othman Mohamed Othman admitted that the eurozone’s debt crisis would hamper the local economy, noting that over 40% of the nation’s exports go to EU-member countries.

That could put a halt to Egypt’s ambitious growth goals, which include effectively doubling exports in the next five years.

Othman did not go into detail on just how adverse the effects would be, instead focusing on Egypt’s positive GDP results for FY2008/09, which the government forecasts will jump from 4.7% to more than 5%.

He said his ministry would continue to monitor Greece’s situation via a committee now being formed.

But unlike the government, economists here aren’t pulling their punches.

“This crisis is much worse than the Dubai financial crisis,” says economist Ahmed El-Sayed El-Naggar from the Al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies.

“[It] is much farther reaching and [will be] more costly.”

The damage to the tourism sector and foreign investment in Egypt will depend on how the euro fares in the coming months and whether the eurozone will be able to boost investor confidence, he says.

A Greek Tragedy

Greek protesters took to the streets in May, angered over the government’s decision to cut salaries, pensions and other benefits for civil servants.

The cuts, part and parcel of bailout terms from the IMF and the EU, are set to affect a huge portion of the labor force as the government employs almost one third of Greece’s workforce.

While unpopular, Greek authorities say the budget cuts and tax hikes are necessary to raise 30 billion (LE 204 billion) in just three years in order to cut the country’s sovereign debt. (Currently Greece’s debt stands at 115% of its GDP. Its deficit is over 12% of GDP.)

Economists worry that the bailout has actually made the situation worse since it will add billions more to Greece’s debt and could potentially force another crisis, should the government be unable to repay investors a second time.

The austerity package passed by the Greeks could also prolong the nation’s recession.

Deflating economies are particularly risky investments because there is no growth to provide the government with ready cash.

Egypt could face even worse straits should the euro dip further against the dollar, making it increasingly difficult for struggling EU countries to recover and grow in the future.

“The euro is bad for non-competitive economies, like Italy, Spain and Portugal,” says Trevisani. “Germany, and to some degree France, have high value exports, so they can support an expensive welfare state.

“The Greeks don’t make Mercedes.”

European Promises

So far the Egyptian government’s hopes of achieving GDP growth of over 5% have remained stymied.

According to the Ministry of Finance, net foreign direct investment is still down compared to the same period a year ago. It reached $4.3 billion (LE 24 billion) between July 2009 and March 2010 compared to $5.2 billion (LE 29 billion) the period before, despite growth in 3Q2010.

Real GDP growth has risen, albeit slowly, hitting 4.8% for the first half of FY2009/10.

Exports have also seen a decline of 9.8% during the first half of the fiscal year, though officials still say GDP growth of 5.3% is achievable. Egypt needs to post strong 4Q results to attain its goal, which likely won’t be on the cards now that the eurozone has thrown investors into a state of confusion, says El-Naggar.

The less than stellar results are being compounded by fewer aid dollars. In March, the EU promised Egypt 450 million (LE 3.3 billion) for the next three years to help speed economic reform, but analysts worry that Europe won’t keep that promise. Egypt reported $4 billion (LE 22 billion) in development assistance in FY2008/09. This year the amount has dwindled to $1.6 billion (LE 8.8 billion) as of March.

Though the government is endeavoring to move away from foreign aid, now is not the time for lenders to be tightening purse strings if Egypt is to achieve any of its growth goals, says El-Naggar.

“I think the amount of foreign direct investment and aid money could decrease,” he says. bt

  About bt Egyptbt jobs & freelancingadvertise with usPrivacy policyContact us  
  Business Today Egypt, @ 2004-2007 IBA Media
Site developed, hosted, and maintained by Gazayerli Group Egypt